Mary Cassatt
Biography
Themes in Their Work
Featured in Essays
Essay
The Courtesan Behind the Sword
Start in a rented room with a curtain pulled high. A banker is waiting for a deliverable; a patronage network is watching a comet of a painter. Caravaggio steps to the canvas and chooses his Judith — not a saint from a sermon, but a woman Rome’s police could name. “And she smote twice upon his neck, and cut off his head.” The Book of Judith gives the script. Caravaggio turns it into live theater.
Essay
The Day Manet Took a Knife to His Own Painting
Paris, 1864. The Salon is the arena. A painting can knight you or end you. Manet, already bruised by scandal the year before, bets big on spectacle: a sweeping bullfight scene, Spanish costume, blood and bravado. He hangs it for the crowd. The critics circle. The verdict is icy. He can’t afford another public drubbing; every jeer dents his chances of becoming more than a punchline. The stakes are career, pride, and Paris itself. Here’s the twist sitting in plain sight: the famous close‑up of the fallen matador you know as The Dead Toreador — you can see it here [link](/artworks/edouard-manet/the-dead-toreador)[1] — started life as just one corner of that doomed panorama.
Essay
The Iron and the Eye: Degas Against the Glare
By the mid‑1870s, collectors wanted Degas for ballet: satin shoes, mirrored studios, the sellable dream. Instead, he kept showing up in steam and starch. Over and over, he painted laundresses—women who boiled, beat, and pressed other people’s clothes for pennies in rooms as hot as kilns. The choice wasn’t neutral; it could stall sales and annoy patrons who preferred dancers to drudgery. But Degas wouldn’t look away. The Musée d’Orsay calls this an obsession, tracing versions of ironers across the decade, including the famous yawning pair in Repasseuses [1].
Essay
The Blue Armchair Rebellion
Paris, 1878. An American woman is fighting for entry into the most controversial circle in art. Reputation on the line, money scarce, critics circling. Her next move must land. She paints… a kid who won’t behave. A small girl slumps diagonally across a vast sea of turquoise upholstery, socks rumpled, gaze elsewhere, a terrier comatose on a neighboring chair. It looks unbothered, even rude. And that’s the point. In a market that rewarded sugarcoated childhood, Mary Cassatt risked everything on a portrait that shrugs at adult decorum [1]. Cassatt had just thrown in with the outsiders—at Degas’s urging—and was preparing for her first Impressionist exhibition the following year. It wasn’t a club you entered softly. “I accepted with joy,” she later said of the invitation, because the Salon “crushed all originality” [3]. If this picture failed, the doubters would say she didn’t belong.
Essay
The Balcony That Started a Riot
Picture the stakes. Paris still bowed to the Salon, a jury that could mint careers or erase them. Monet had a young family, debts, and a dwindling market. So he and a handful of friends did the unthinkable: rent the grand studio of star photographer Nadar at 35 Boulevard des Capucines and hang their own show—no permission, no jury, all risk. The vantage in this painting is that balcony, that window, that leap.[2][7]
Essay
Degas’s Vanished Paris: The Painting That Went to War and Came Back With a Secret
Start in 1875: a man strides, girls in gray keep pace, a dog scouts the pavement. No one looks at each other. A city square yawns like a stage. Edgar Degas freezes it all with brutal cuts at the frame, the visual grammar of a world too fast for eye contact. Today the canvas lives at the State Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, a long way from the Paris square it depicts—and even farther from where it was last seen before the war [State Hermitage Museum](https://hermitagemuseum.org/digital-collection/29681?lng=en)[1].
Essay
The Audition in Blue: Renoir’s Gamble Behind Girl with a Watering Can
Picture Renoir at 35, debts circling, reputation wobbling after the second Impressionist show. The critics mocked his circle; the market yawned. Portrait commissions — the cash engine of Paris — kept going to establishment names. He had to change that or sink. [National Gallery, London](https://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/artists/pierre-auguste-renoir) [2].
Essay
The Picnic That Made an Emperor Blink
Start with the stakes: the Paris Salon decided an artist’s fate. Win the jury, you get buyers, critics, immortality. Lose, you vanish. That year, the jury rejected an unusually high number of submissions. Among the refusés was a picnic with a stare that wouldn’t look away—Édouard Manet’s Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe, then called Le Bain. The museum that owns it now says flatly: it “caused a scandal.” [Musée d’Orsay](https://www.musee-orsay.fr/en/artworks/le-dejeuner-sur-lherbe-904) [1].
Essay
She Put Down the Fan
Look closely: the props of flirtation lie useless in the grass. The fan is shut. The green parasol is abandoned. A carriage blurs by in the distance, but the figure never looks up. She reads, and the world waits. Morisot painted this in 1873, her surface quick and alive, the scene almost dissolving around the reader’s concentration. The Cleveland Museum of Art calls it Reading; it’s small, disarming, and dangerously calm [2].
Essay
Renoir’s Fake Date Night
Picture the stakes: Renoir is thirty-three, broke, and rolling the dice on a renegade show the Salon has snubbed—the first Impressionist exhibition. If this painting doesn’t spark attention, he’s not just unfashionable; he’s finished.
Essay
The Sunniest Monet Was Painted in a Storm
First glance: a perfect day. Parasols tilt. White sails cut the Channel. Sun freckles the water like confetti. It looks like a rich man’s postcard. That’s the trap.
Essay
Monet’s Pink Parasol, and the Secret It Was Hiding
Start at the edge. In 1882 Monet escaped to a fishing village on the Normandy coast and worked like a man trying to outrun gossip. He had fallen in love with Alice Hoschedé, the wife of his former patron Ernest, whose finances had collapsed. Two households had fused into one. The art world was watching, and not kindly [4].
Essay
The Night Pissarro Learned to See Again
He was in his mid‑sixties, the elder statesman of Impressionism with bills to pay and younger stars sprinting past. Critics loved the myth of Pissarro the tireless outdoor painter. But his reality was uglier: an infection had made bright, dusty daylight brutal. So he moved indoors and up—into a rented high window on the Boulevard Montmartre—staking his reputation on whether a man who couldn’t face the sun could still paint light.[5]
Essay
The Mirror That Said No: Berthe Morisot’s Quiet Rebellion
Look at the setup: a woman in satin, arm lifted, powders and jars within reach. Paris, late 1870s. It reads like flirtation. But the reflection is a smear, the face withheld. Morisot built a trap for the viewer and sprung it with a brush.
Essay
The Pink Portrait the Revolution Seized
Start in 1877. Renoir is broke, ambitious, and tired of being called a lightweight. He paints a young actress from the Comédie‑Française—Jeanne Samary—with a coral-pink atmosphere and a sea‑green dress, a portrait designed to charm the Salon and the paying classes. The picture glows like a debutante’s rumor. It still does. See it up close on our artwork page: /artworks/pierre-auguste-renoir/portrait-of-jeanne-samary.
Essay
The Prettiest SOS on the Seine
Picture Renoir at thirty-four, rent due, reputation wobbling. He’s fresh from the first Impressionist shockwaves and a Paris press that mocked his friends as incompetents. One reviewer sneered that Renoir painted a woman’s body like “a mass of decomposing flesh with green and purple spots.”[4] The message was clear: stop, or starve.
Essay
The Wheatfield Myth: Van Gogh’s Stormiest Painting Isn’t a Suicide Note
Scroll any feed and you’ll meet this image: a blasted-blue sky, a road that forks and dies, black birds like shrapnel. The caption is almost always the same: his last canvas, his farewell. Our shiver becomes the story.
Essay
Renoir’s Sweetest Breakup
You know this image: a couple under a living arbor, hands grazing over a café table. Soft light. Soft edges. Soft story. Except the year is 1885, and Pierre‑Auguste Renoir is in crisis. The painter who helped spark Impressionism is suddenly telling friends he no longer knows how to paint. The romance on canvas hides a rupture off it.[3][10]
Essay
The Day Monet Turned a Picnic into a Comeback
Start here: a hill at Argenteuil, a flash of white dress, a boy blinking in the wind. The painting feels tossed-off and weightless. That’s the trick. Because months earlier, the money and the mood were brutal. In 1875, fresh from the first Impressionist exhibition’s ridicule, Monet and friends tried an auction at Hôtel Drouot. The crowd jeered, prices collapsed, and police were called. His name became shorthand for recklessness with paint, not value. The family’s comfort—rent, food, even paint—was on the line. The parasol wasn’t shade; it was cover. Monet needed an image that could flip the narrative: not starving bohemians, but modern life, bright and breathable, the very leisure new suburban rail lines were selling. Argenteuil was Paris’s weekend playground—sailboats, strolls, picnics, and status on display—exactly the world collectors fancied seeing on their walls.
Essay
The Cradle Was a Warning, Not a Lullaby
Paris, 1874. A young painter stakes her reputation on a domestic scene while her comrades hang boats, boulevards, and fog. Berthe Morisot chooses a nursery. Money, credibility, and a seat at the table are on the line—because if the public writes her off as merely “feminine,” she’s finished.
Essay
The Cathedral That Took Monet Hostage
The postcard version is easy: stone lace, soft color, Impressionism behaving. But Monet’s cathedral wasn’t decor. It was a duel with the sun, run on minutes and panic, with a dealer betting that the public would finally understand what Impressionism had been saying all along.
Essay
The Woman Paris Refused to See
The Salon was the only career ladder that mattered. Manet needed it. Respectability, buyers, a future—hung on a wall in 1865. Then the crowd arrived, and the painting that wouldn’t behave drew jeers so thick the museum put up a cord to protect it. The Musée d’Orsay is blunt about the reception: scandal, fury, and a guard between public and paint.
Essay
The $65 Million Spring
Christie’s, New York, 2014. Phones light up. The bidding climbs past the price of many houses, then many museums’ annual acquisitions budgets. When the hammer falls, Manet’s Jeanne (Spring) shatters a record and the Getty wins the picture for $65.1 million—a new pinnacle for the artist at auction [3][1].
Essay
The Night Degas Put the Ballerinas in the Back Row
Picture Paris in the late 1860s: velvet boxes, diamonded patrons, ballerinas floating like chandeliers. And then an unknown painter plants his easel where no one is looking—down in the orchestra pit. Why risk it? Because reputation was on the line. Degas was switching gears, ditching history painting for modern life, and the Opéra was the city’s most ruthless stage: art, money, and gossip in a single address.[1] If he chose wrong, he’d stay a nobody. He also had a personal stake. The man gripping that diagonal bassoon is Désiré Dihau—a real friend, a working musician whose salary depended on staying visible to an audience that never looked his way.[2][3] Degas knew the rules of this house, and he was about to break them on canvas.
Essay
Monet’s Quiet Bridge, Built on Noise
In 1893, Monet walked into local bureaucracy with a radical request: let me reroute a stream and build a lily pond in my backyard. Farmers objected, fearing floods and foreign plants. The painter pushed through anyway, secured permission, and set about reshaping the land at Giverny. The tranquil bridge you know was born out of paperwork and protests, not Zen stillness. [1] Money and reputation were on the line. Monet had finally bought his home in 1890 after years of financial precarity; now he was risking cash and goodwill to turn a garden into a studio—and a studio into a legacy. He wasn’t just planting; he was betting his name. He staged the scene with precision: a curved wooden span, no horizon, and a pond thick with lilies. This wasn’t picturesque chance—it was design. The bridge, lifted from the era’s mania for Japan, signaled a fashionable cool while tightening the composition like a drum. As the National Gallery in London notes, the structure arrived alongside Paris’s craze for Japanese art and prints, which Monet collected obsessively. [2] Then came the first payoff: in 1899, he painted it. If you think the image recorded a walk in the park, consider how hard he worked to make the park exist. The Japanese Footbridge compresses space, removes the sky, and turns reflection into theater, a trick he could repeat at will from his doorstep. [1] [5]
Essay
The Prettiest Sunset in Art Was Air Pollution
He arrived not for Parliament’s Gothic drama but for the weather report. From a window on the south bank, Monet lined up the towers and waited for the sky to burn through the haze. The National Gallery of Art notes he finished the canvas in 1903, after returning to Giverny to tune the color of the Thames like a violin string—then unveiled the London series in 1904, betting his mature reputation on a city that barely wanted to be seen at all. [NGA link][1]
Essay
Monet Booked the Steam
Monet was in his late thirties and still not a sure thing. The Impressionists had split with the Salon, but the public wasn’t buying in bulk. He needed a subject that felt undeniable—modern, popular, unmistakably Paris. He picked the engine room of the city itself: the Gare Saint-Lazare, the Western Railway’s iron-and-glass cathedral of departures.
Essay
Grit in the Light: Monet’s Trouville, Captured Not Just Seen
Stand before the National Gallery’s Beach at Trouville and the composition immediately leans into you: a boardwalk pulled taut on the diagonal, parasols opening like sails, and a regiment of red flags firing toward the Channel. The confection of hotels to the right—anchored by the fashionable Hôtel des Roches Noires—presses the promenade into a stage for modern leisure, a Second Empire theater of strolling and display. Monet painted it on site in the summer of 1870, a blustery day made legible by architecture and cloth rather than narrative incident, as the museum’s entry for the work recounts ([The Beach at Trouville](https://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/claude-monet-the-beach-at-trouville) [1]). [Image: Beach at Trouville (1870) — /artworks/claude-monet/beach-at-trouville] That slanted boardwalk does more than guide the eye: it sets a vector. From left surf to right-hand steps, every stroke queues to the wind’s push, a coastal physics lesson rendered in broken blues and bleached ochres.
Essay
The Wind Is the Protagonist: Monet’s Beach at Trouville as a Pre-Digital Live Feed
Beach at Trouville looks, at first glance, like a souvenir of a fashionable afternoon: sun-struck planks, white parasols, genteel promenaders. But every element is drafted into a single task—measuring the air. The diagonal boardwalk hurries the eye past the figures; a volley of red flags snaps mid-gust; skirts and veils flare into vectors. In Monet’s 1870 season at the Normandy resort, modern leisure had met meteorology—tourism built to be felt in motion [2][4]. [Artwork: /artworks/claude-monet/beach-at-trouville] That sense of motion anchors the canvas in a specific place and moment. Trouville had exploded into a Second Empire playground, its grand hotels and villas marching right up to the sand. Monet painted those very facades elsewhere that same season, including the newly fashionable Hôtel des Roches Noires—a statement of seaside modernity still rising from the dunes [1].
Most Expensive Mary Cassatt Paintings
Explore ranked valuations of Mary Cassatt's most valuable works →
Featured Artworks
Woman in Black at the Opera
Mary Cassatt (1878)
Mary Cassatt’s Woman in Black at the Opera stages a taut drama of vision and visibility. A woman in <strong>black attire</strong> raises <strong>opera glasses</strong> while a distant man aims his own at her, setting off a chain of looks that makes public leisure a site of <strong>power, agency, and surveillance</strong> <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
The Tea
Mary Cassatt (about 1880)
Mary Cassatt’s The Tea stages a poised, interior <strong>drama of manners</strong>: two women sit close yet feel apart, one thoughtful, the other raising a cup that <strong>veils her face</strong>. A gleaming, oversized <strong>silver tea service</strong> commands the foreground, its reflections turning ritual objects into actors in the scene <sup>[1]</sup>. The shallow, cropped room—striped wall, gilt mirror, marble mantel—compresses the atmosphere into <strong>intimacy edged by restraint</strong>.
Little Girl in a Big Straw Hat and a Pinafore
Mary Cassatt (c. 1886)
Mary Cassatt’s Little Girl in a Big Straw Hat and a Pinafore distills childhood into a quiet drama of <strong>interiority</strong> and <strong>constraint</strong>. The oversized straw hat and plain pinafore bracket a flushed face, downcast eyes, and <strong>clasped hands</strong>, turning a simple pose into a study of modern self‑consciousness <sup>[1]</sup>. Cassatt’s cool grays and swift, luminous strokes make mood—not costume—the subject.
Breakfast in Bed
Mary Cassatt (1897)
Breakfast in Bed distills a <strong>tender modern intimacy</strong> into a tightly cropped sanctuary of rumpled white linens, protective embrace, and interrupted routine. Mary Cassatt uses <strong>cool light</strong> against <strong>warm flesh</strong> to anchor attention on the mother’s encircling arm and the child’s outward gaze, fusing care, curiosity, and the rhythms of <strong>everyday modern life</strong> <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
Young Mother Sewing
Mary Cassatt (1900)
Mary Cassatt’s Young Mother Sewing centers the quiet <strong>labor of care</strong>: a mother steadies pale fabric while a child in white leans into her, eyes meeting ours. Cool <strong>greens and blues</strong> bathe the figures as striped sleeves and chair arms rhythmically return attention to the mother’s working hands, while a burst of <strong>orange blossoms</strong> by the window anchors interior life against the world outside <sup>[1]</sup>.
Children Playing on the Beach
Mary Cassatt (1884)
In Children Playing on the Beach, Mary Cassatt brings the viewer down to a child’s eye level, granting everyday play the weight of <strong>serious, self-contained work</strong>. The cool horizon and tiny boats open onto <strong>modern space and possibility</strong>, while the cropped, tilted foreground seals us inside the children’s focused world <sup>[1]</sup>.
A Woman and a Girl Driving
Mary Cassatt (1881)
Cassatt stages a modern scene of <strong>female control</strong> in motion: a woman grips the reins and whip while a girl beside her mirrors the pose, and a groom seated behind looks away. The cropped horse and diagonal harness thrust the carriage forward, placing viewers inside a public outing in the Bois de Boulogne—an arena where visibility signaled status and autonomy <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
Girl Arranging Her Hair
Mary Cassatt (1886)
Mary Cassatt’s Girl Arranging Her Hair crystallizes a private rite of <strong>self‑regard</strong> into modern painting. Cool, broken strokes of the pale chemise meet the warm, patterned wall and bamboo furniture, staging a quiet drama of <strong>autonomy</strong> rather than display <sup>[1]</sup>. Exhibited in 1886, the work reframes the toilette as lived experience within Impressionism’s language of immediacy <sup>[2]</sup>.
Reading Le Figaro
Mary Cassatt (c. 1878–83)
Mary Cassatt’s Reading Le Figaro turns a quiet parlor into a scene of <strong>intellect</strong> and <strong>modern life</strong>. The inverted masthead, mirrored repetition of the paper, and the sitter’s spectacles make <strong>attention</strong>—not appearance—the true subject <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[4]</sup>. Through brisk whites and grays, Cassatt dignifies everyday thought as a modern pictorial theme aligned with <strong>Impressionism</strong> <sup>[2]</sup>.
Summertime
Mary Cassatt (1894)
Mary Cassatt’s Summertime (1894) stages a quiet drama of <strong>attentive looking</strong>: a woman and a girl lean from a cropped boat toward two ducks as the lake flickers with broken color. Cassatt fuses <strong>Impressionism</strong> and <strong>Japonisme</strong>—no horizon, tipped perspective, and abrupt cropping—to press our gaze downward into light-spattered water. The result is an image of <strong>modern leisure</strong> that is also a study of perception itself <sup>[1]</sup>.
Portrait of Alexander J. Cassatt and His Son Robert Kelso Cassatt
Mary Cassatt (1884)
A quiet, domestic tableau becomes a study in <strong>authority tempered by affection</strong>. In Portrait of Alexander J. Cassatt and His Son Robert Kelso Cassatt, Mary Cassatt fuses father and child into a single dark silhouette against a luminous, brushed interior, their shared gaze fixed beyond the frame. The <strong>newspaper</strong>, <strong>linked hands</strong>, and <strong>cropped closeness</strong> transform a routine moment into a symbol of generational continuity and modern attentiveness.
The Boating Party
Mary Cassatt (1893–1894)
In The Boating Party, Mary Cassatt fuses <strong>intimate caregiving</strong> with <strong>modern mobility</strong>, compressing mother, child, and rower inside a skiff that cuts diagonals across ultramarine water. Bold arcs of citron paint and a high, flattened horizon reveal a deliberate <strong>Japonisme</strong> logic that stabilizes the scene even as motion surges around it <sup>[1]</sup>. The painting asserts domestic life as a public, modern subject while testing the limits of Impressionist space and color.
The Child's Bath
Mary Cassatt (1893)
Mary Cassatt’s The Child’s Bath (1893) recasts an ordinary ritual as <strong>modern devotion</strong>. From a steep, print-like vantage, interlocking stripes, circles, and diagonals focus attention on <strong>touch, care, and renewal</strong>, turning domestic labor into a subject of high art <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[3]</sup>. The work synthesizes Impressionist sensitivity with <strong>Japonisme</strong> design to monumentalize the private sphere <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
The Cup of Tea
Mary Cassatt (ca. 1880–81)
Mary Cassatt’s The Cup of Tea distills a moment of bourgeois leisure into a study of <strong>poise</strong>, <strong>etiquette</strong>, and <strong>private reflection</strong>. A woman in a rose‑pink dress and bonnet, white‑gloved, balances a gold‑rimmed cup against the shimmer of <strong>Impressionist</strong> brushwork, while a green planter of pale blossoms echoes her pastel palette <sup>[1]</sup>. The work turns an ordinary ritual into a modern emblem of women’s experience.
Little Girl in a Blue Armchair
Mary Cassatt (1878)
Mary Cassatt’s Little Girl in a Blue Armchair renders a child slumped diagonally across an oversized seat, surrounded by a flotilla of blue chairs and cool window light. With brisk, broken strokes and a skewed recession, Cassatt asserts a modern, unsentimental view of childhood—bored, autonomous, and <strong>out of step with adult decorum</strong> <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[4]</sup>. Subtle collaboration with <strong>Degas</strong> in the background design sharpens the picture’s daring spatial thrust <sup>[2]</sup>.
In the Loge
Mary Cassatt (1878)
Mary Cassatt’s In the Loge (1878) stages modern spectatorship as a drama of <strong>mutual looking</strong>. A woman in dark dress leans forward with <strong>opera glasses</strong>, her <strong>fan closed</strong> on her lap, as a man in the distance raises his own glasses toward her—turning the theater into a circuit of gazes <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
Woman with a Pearl Necklace in a Loge
Mary Cassatt (1879)
Mary Cassatt’s Woman with a Pearl Necklace in a Loge (1879) stages modern <strong>spectatorship</strong> inside a plush opera box, where a young woman in pink satin, pearls, and gloves occupies the red velvet seat while a mirror multiplies the chandeliers and balconies. Cassatt fuses <strong>intimacy</strong> and <strong>public display</strong>, using luminous brushwork to place her sitter within the social theater of Parisian leisure <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[2]</sup>.
Lady at the Tea Table
Mary Cassatt (1883–85 (signed 1885))
Mary Cassatt’s Lady at the Tea Table distills a domestic rite into a scene of <strong>quiet authority</strong>. The sitter’s black silhouette, lace cap, and poised hand marshal a regiment of <strong>cobalt‑and‑gold Canton porcelain</strong>, while tight cropping and planar light convert hospitality into <strong>modern self‑possession</strong> <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[5]</sup>.
Self-Portrait
Mary Cassatt (1878)
In Self-Portrait, Mary Cassatt presents a poised, <strong>modern woman</strong> angled diagonally across a striped chair, her gaze turned away in <strong>thoughtful reserve</strong>. A <strong>sage-olive ground</strong> and tight crop strip away setting, while the <strong>white dress</strong> flickers with lilacs and blues against a <strong>decisive red ribbon</strong> and floral bonnet. The image asserts <strong>professional selfhood</strong> through restraint, asymmetry, and broken color.<sup>[1]</sup>
Mother About to Wash Her Sleepy Child
Mary Cassatt (1880)
Mary Cassatt’s Mother About to Wash Her Sleepy Child (1880) turns an ordinary bedtime ritual into a scene of <strong>caregiving, labor, and modern intimacy</strong>. Cropped close, with the child’s legs diagonally splayed and a tilted washbowl at the mother’s knee, the picture translates domestic routine into a <strong>modern Madonna</strong> for the bourgeois interior. Its flickering blues and milky whites, plus patterned upholstery and wallpaper, signal Cassatt’s <strong>Impressionist</strong> and japonisme-inflected design sense <sup>[2]</sup>.
Mother and Child (The Oval Mirror)
Mary Cassatt (ca. 1899)
Mary Cassatt’s Mother and Child (The Oval Mirror) turns a routine act of care into a <strong>modern icon</strong>. An oval mirror <strong>haloes</strong> the child while interlaced hands and close bodies make <strong>touch</strong> the vehicle of meaning <sup>[1]</sup><sup>[3]</sup>.